All-Americans

1926

Loyd Yoder

1928

Howard Harpster

1979

Robert Gasior
Don Kaminski
Gusty Sunseri

1981

Donnie Kiminski
Ken Murawski (AFCA)

1982

Harley Carroll
Bill Kiselick
Mark Leposky
Mike O'Ship

1983

Scott Bachik
Ross Jicomelli
Mike O'Donnell

1985

Robert Butts (AFCA)

1989

Chris Balouris
Scott Barnyak
Paul Brinsky
Russell Hann
Gale King
Robert O'Toole

1990

Scott Barnyak
Robert O'Toole
Jim Rose

1991

Andy Helms
Mike Hession
Chuck Jackson
Rich Wilson

1992

Andy Helms
Chuck Jackson
Griffin Pero
Matt Pielert
Chad Wilson
Rich Wilson

1993

Ben Burton
Chris Dee
Chad Wilson

1994

Merle Atkinson
Chris Dee
Mark Kasperowicz
Kevin Keir
Rob Locke
Aaron Neal

2000

Nick Zitelli (AFCA)
Nick Zitelli (AP)
Matt Young (D3football)

2003

Chad Zimmerman

2005

Aaron Lewis (D3football)

2006

Aaron Lewis (D3football)
J.P. White (D3football)

2012

Sam Thompson (BSN)

2015

Sam Benger (AFCA)
Sam Benger (AP)
Sam Benger (D3football)
Drew Fitzmorris (D3football)
Andrew Garibaldi (D3football)
Brian Khoury (D3football)

2016

Sam Benger (AFCA)
Sam Benger (D3football)

2017

Tyler Kohman (AFCA)
Tyler Kohman (AP)
Tyler Kohman (D3football)
Drew Fitzmorris (D3football)

2020-21

Sean Pogorelc (D3football)

2021

Tre Vasiliadis (D3football)

2022

Robert Coury (AFCA)
Robert Coury (AP)
Robert Coury (D3football)

2023

Robert Coury (AFCA)
Robert Coury (AP)
Robert Coury (D3football)